GameCompass LogoGameCompass

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin

Game images by RAWG

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin

BANDAI NAMCO Entertainment America

PC, Xbox One, PlayStation 4Premium
Health Score
63
GOOD

About This Game

Super Review

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin is a dark fantasy action RPG renowned for its brutal difficulty and rewarding, strategic combat. Players will repeatedly face overwhelming odds, demanding patience and persistence to overcome. While a complete, premium package, parents should be aware of graphic combat, dark horror themes, and online interactions with strangers, making it a qualified fit for mature older teens.

Super Review

Parent verdict

This challenging action RPG is a good fit for older teens who thrive on extreme difficulty and appreciate deep combat mechanics, provided parents are comfortable with its mature content and online features. The game’s focus on learning from failure and strategic planning offers a unique sense of accomplishment. However, its graphic combat, dark imagery, and online interactions require careful consideration and parental guidance, preventing it from being a universal recommendation despite its value as a complete package.

What players actually do

  • Players explore the ruined kingdom of Drangleic, navigating oppressive environments and discovering hidden paths and secrets.
  • Players engage in deliberate, challenging combat against a wide array of monsters and powerful bosses using swords, shields, and magic, learning enemy patterns and weaknesses.
  • Players customize their character extensively, shaping their appearance, distributing stat points, and equipping various weapons and armor to develop a unique playstyle.
  • Players repeatedly die and learn from their mistakes, adapting strategies and persevering through punishing mechanics that reduce maximum health after each death until restored.
  • Players can summon other online players for cooperative help against bosses or choose to invade other players' worlds for competitive player-versus-player engagements.

Where it shines

  • The game strongly rewards patience, persistence, and strategic thinking, as players must meticulously learn enemy behaviors and adapt after each defeat to progress.
  • Extensive character customization allows players to deeply personalize their avatar, stats, and gear to create a build that perfectly suits their preferred combat style, fostering a sense of ownership.
  • The inclusion of all three expansion campaigns in a single purchase provides significant content and value, ensuring no further in-game buying is required.

Parent watch-outs

  • Combat is graphically intense for a fantasy game, featuring frequent depictions of blood and gore alongside dark and often disturbing environments.
  • The game's difficulty is intentionally brutal, and repeated deaths are a core mechanic that can lead to intense frustration, especially as maximum health is steadily reduced.
  • Online multiplayer connects players with strangers for both cooperative assistance and competitive player-versus-player invasions, introducing unpredictable social interactions.
  • The pervasive dark fantasy horror imagery includes unsettling undead enemies and grim boss designs that contribute to a consistently oppressive atmosphere.

Family rules worth setting

  • Set clear session time limits to manage potential frustration from repeated deaths and prevent excessive engagement in a challenging game.
  • Discuss strategies for managing online interactions, particularly concerning invasions, and ensure privacy settings are understood and utilized.
  • Establish guidelines around mature content, particularly the graphic combat and dark themes, considering the individual maturity level of the player.
  • Consider co-op play as a supervised activity, perhaps with an older sibling or parent, to mitigate some of the frustration and monitor online exposure.

Talk about this

  • How do you manage frustration when a game is extremely difficult? What coping strategies can you use?
  • What are the risks and benefits of playing online with strangers, and how can you stay safe in online environments?
  • How do dark or violent themes in games make you feel, and what's the difference between fantasy violence and real-world violence?
  • Why might a game offer all its content in one purchase versus having many smaller purchases, and what are the pros and cons of each approach?

Play style

Sessions can vary from short, intense bursts focusing on a single encounter to longer exploratory periods. The difficulty is extremely high, demanding careful planning and precise execution, making it unsuitable for casual play. Players will frequently die, necessitating patience and a willingness to learn from failure. The game is primarily a single-player experience, but cooperative and competitive online modes allow for social interaction, though parental supervision is advised for younger players due to interactions with strangers. Younger players may need significant help navigating the difficulty and managing frustration.

Score Breakdown

Positive Aspects

Educational Value
2/5
Creativity
3/5
Pro-Social
3/5

Risk Factors

Addictive Monetization
0/5
Time Pressure / FOMO
0/5
Social Risk
3/5
Content Intensity
3/5

Why this rating

Educational Value

2/5

While not designed for education, the game's brutal difficulty implicitly fosters skills like patience, strategic thinking, and problem-solving through its 'learn from failure' design. The score of 2 reflects these indirect benefits without claiming explicit educational content.

Addictive Monetization

0/5

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin is a premium title that includes the base game and all DLC in a single purchase. There are no microtransactions, loot boxes, or other addictive monetization schemes, resulting in a perfect score of 0.

Social Risk

3/5

The game includes online multiplayer features, allowing players to summon strangers for co-op or be invaded by other players for PvP. This direct interaction with unknown individuals carries a moderate social risk, justifying a score of 3.

Content Intensity

3/5

Content intensity is high due to graphic combat with blood and gore, pervasive dark fantasy horror imagery, partial nudity in some character designs, and mild profanity. These elements contribute to its 'M' (ESRB) / PEGI 16 rating, aligning with a score of 3.

Negatives

  • •Combat is graphic for a fantasy game, with depictions of blood and gore alongside dark, oppressive environments
  • •The difficulty is intentionally brutal, and repeated deaths steadily reduce the character's maximum health, which can be intensely frustrating
  • •Online play connects players with strangers for both cooperative summoning and player-versus-player invasions
  • •Dark fantasy horror imagery, including undead enemies and grim boss designs, runs throughout the game
  • •Some character designs include partial nudity, and dialogue contains mild profanity

Positives

  • •Rewards patience, persistence and strategic planning, as players must learn enemy patterns and adapt after each defeat
  • •Deep character customization lets players shape appearance, stats, weapons and armor to suit their own playstyle
  • •Cooperative play lets players summon one another for help against bosses, encouraging teamwork toward a shared goal
  • •A single purchase includes the full game and all three expansion campaigns, with no further buying required
  • •An active modding community offers extra ways for older players to tinker with visuals and interfaces

Gameplay Videos

Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin - Forlorn Hope Trailer

Bandai Namco Entertainment America

1 of 3

Official Ratings

M
ESRB

Age Fit

ℹ️Ages 3-5
Not suitable — features intense dark fantasy horror imagery, graphic combat, and punishing death mechanics.
ℹ️Ages 6-8
Not suitable — features intense dark fantasy horror imagery, graphic combat, and punishing death mechanics.
ℹ️Ages 9-12
Not suitable — features intense dark fantasy horror imagery, graphic combat, and punishing death mechanics.
ℹ️Ages 13-15
Not recommended for this age group due to intense mature content, including graphic violence, dark themes, and online interactions.
ℹ️Ages 16-18
Suitable with parental supervision for older teens (16+) who appreciate extreme difficulty and mature themes, and can manage online interactions responsibly. Content includes graphic combat, dark horror, and online player interaction.

Help us rate the next game

GameCompass is free for every family and takes nothing from game studios. A coffee is what puts the next game on the list.

Buy us a coffeeWhat support pays for