Dark Souls III
BANDAI NAMCO Entertainment America
About This Game
Super ReviewDark Souls III offers a rich, challenging dark fantasy adventure for patient players, emphasizing strategic combat and exploration. Its unforgiving difficulty and mature themes, alongside competitive online interactions, mean it's best suited for older, mature teens and requires clear parental guidance.
Super Review
Parent verdict
Dark Souls III is a qualified fit for older teens who appreciate a demanding, strategic action RPG. Its 'Decent' health score reflects the strong core gameplay and lack of aggressive monetization, balanced against its intense content and potential for frustrating difficulty. Parents should consider this title for mature players capable of handling its dark themes, persistent violence, and competitive online elements, setting clear boundaries around multiplayer interactions.
What players actually do
- Players engage in challenging, close-quarters combat against monstrous enemies, learning attack patterns and practicing precise timing and dodging to survive.
- Players explore a vast, interconnected dark fantasy world, discovering hidden paths, lore details, and valuable items, which rewards curiosity and observation.
- Players customize their character with various weapons, armor, and magic, adapting their build and combat style to overcome specific enemy types and boss encounters.
Where it shines
- The game provides significant opportunities for strategic thinking and persistence, as players must analyze enemy weaknesses and refine their combat approach to overcome difficult challenges.
- Its dark fantasy world is meticulously designed, offering a compelling atmosphere and intricate level layouts that encourage thorough exploration and reward players who delve deep into its lore.
Parent watch-outs
- The gameplay is centered around frequent defeats and trial-and-error, which can be a source of frustration and may not suit all players.
- Online interactions include player-versus-player invasions, where unknown players can enter a game to attack, leading to potentially confrontational or unpleasant experiences.
Family rules worth setting
- Set a time limit for play sessions, especially when facing difficult areas, to prevent frustration from prolonged defeats.
- Discuss and agree on specific guidelines for online play, particularly regarding player-versus-player interactions, to manage social exposure.
Talk about this
- How do you handle frustration and repeated failures in games? What strategies do you use to overcome difficult challenges?
- When playing online, what are appropriate ways to interact with strangers, especially when they are competing against you?
Play style
Sessions can vary significantly; players might spend short bursts attempting a boss, or longer periods exploring new areas. The difficulty is consistently high, requiring patience, pattern recognition, and adaptability. Solo play is the primary experience, but cooperative online play is available for tackling tough areas with friends or summoned allies. Players will frequently die and retry, and some may need help identifying optimal strategies or finding hidden paths.
Score Breakdown
Positive Aspects
Risk Factors
Why this rating
Educational Value
2/5Dark Souls III receives an Educational Value score of 2 because while it significantly encourages strategic thinking, problem-solving, and persistence through its challenging gameplay, it lacks explicit academic or learning content. The cognitive benefits are indirect, arising from overcoming its inherent difficulty.
Addictive Monetization
1/5The game scores 1 for Addictive Monetization due to its premium business model and absence of exploitative in-game purchases. Monetization is limited to a one-time purchase and optional, substantial DLC expansions, with no microtransactions, loot boxes, or pay-to-win elements.
Pro-Social
3/5Dark Souls III earns a Pro-Social score of 3, primarily due to its cooperative online multiplayer. Players can summon others to help conquer difficult areas and bosses, fostering teamwork and mutual support. However, competitive player-versus-player invasions somewhat temper this positive aspect.
Social Risk
4/5Social Risk is rated 4 because the game includes player-versus-player invasions, allowing strangers to enter a player's world to initiate combat. While cooperative options exist, the presence of these competitive, uninvited interactions introduces a notable risk of negative or confrontational experiences with other online players.
Content Intensity
3/5With a Content Intensity score of 3, Dark Souls III features challenging combat against monstrous enemies and mature themes set in an apocalyptic world. Violence includes close-combat weaponry with blood effects and persistent dead bodies, contributing to an intense atmosphere suitable for mature audiences, as indicated by its M (Mature) rating.
Negatives
- •The game features challenging and strategic combat with monstrous enemies and themes of an apocalyptic world, which can be intense.
- •Online interactions include player-versus-player invasions, where strangers can enter a player's world to engage in combat.
- •While offering character customization, the game provides limited opportunities for creative content generation or building.
- •The gameplay loop, centered around trial and error and frequent defeats, may be frustrating for some players.
- •Violence includes close-combat weaponry, blood effects, and persistent dead bodies on screen.
Positives
- •Features deep character customization, allowing players to tailor their combat style with various weapons, armor, and magic.
- •Offers significant opportunities for strategic thinking and persistence, as players must learn enemy patterns and overcome difficult challenges through trial and error.
- •Includes cooperative online multiplayer, enabling players to team up with others to conquer difficult areas and bosses.
- •Provides a rich, dark fantasy world to explore with intricate level design and a compelling atmosphere.
- •Does not include daily login rewards or other mechanics designed to create time pressure, allowing players to progress at their own pace.
Other Recommended Games
Project Zomboid
The Indie Stone
Same platform, Same business model, Similar gameplay style, Higher health score
The Orange Box
Valve Software
Same platform, Same business model, Similar gameplay style, Higher health score
Dark Souls: Remastered
FromSoftware
Same platform, Same business model, Similar gameplay style, Higher health score
Grounded 2
Obsidian Entertainment
Same platform, Same business model, Similar gameplay style, Higher health score
Official Ratings
Age Fit
Help us rate the next game
GameCompass is free for every family and takes nothing from game studios. A coffee is what puts the next game on the list.
Buy us a coffeeWhat support pays for