MLB 16: The Show

Game images by RAWG

MLB 16: The Show

Sony Interactive Entertainment

PlayStation 4, PlayStation 3Premium

Health Score

DECENT

Watch Gameplay

About This Game

Super Review

MLB 16: The Show offers a realistic baseball simulation experience for kids who love the sport, combining detailed strategy with the excitement of on-field play. While its career mode encourages creativity and long-term engagement, parents should be mindful of online interactions and an in-game currency system that can subtly push for additional spending to access certain features.

Super Review

Parent verdict

This premium baseball simulation is a qualified fit for dedicated young baseball fans, particularly those 9 and up, who appreciate detailed strategy and player development. Its "Decent" rating reflects a strong core game with educational and creative benefits, balanced by the presence of online player interaction and monetization mechanics in certain modes. Parents should consider this if their child enjoys deep sports simulations and they are prepared to discuss responsible online play and in-game purchases.

What kids actually do

Players will control players in a baseball game, making strategic decisions like pitching choices, batting stances, and base running, which exercises tactical thinking.
Players can create and develop a custom baseball player in "Road to the Show" mode, guiding their career from minor leagues to stardom, fostering creativity and long-term goal setting.
Players can manage an entire baseball team, learning about player statistics, team rosters, and season-long strategies.
Players engage in online matches against others, requiring quick reactions and adaptability to live opponents.

Where it shines

The game provides a deep and strategic simulation of baseball, offering a comprehensive understanding of the sport's rules, player stats, and team management, which can be highly educational for aspiring athletes or statisticians.
The "Road to the Show" mode is a significant highlight, allowing children to invest deeply in a player's journey, making creative choices about their development and playing style.
It offers both local and online multiplayer options, providing opportunities for children to play with friends or against a wide community.

Parent watch-outs

The "Diamond Dynasty" mode includes a card-collecting system for players, where special editions of the game came bundled with in-game currency ("Stubs") and card packs, potentially encouraging a collecting habit that intersects with real money.
Some online game modes require in-game currency to enter after the initial free attempts, which could pressure children to spend real money on "Stubs" if they wish to continue playing these modes.
Online player-versus-player modes expose children to interactions with strangers, which requires parental guidance and discussion about online safety.

Family rules worth setting

Set clear boundaries on online play: restrict interactions to friends only or monitor online sessions, especially for younger players.
Establish a strict "no in-game purchases" rule or set a budget for "Stubs" to prevent unintentional spending within the "Diamond Dynasty" mode and other online features.
Implement time limits for daily play sessions to balance screen time with other activities, particularly given the longer session rhythms of career and season modes.

Talk about this

Discuss the concept of in-game currency and microtransactions: how it works, why companies use it, and the importance of responsible spending habits, even in games.
Talk about online safety and sportsmanship: what information is safe to share (or not share) with strangers online, and how to maintain a positive and respectful attitude during competitive play.
Explore the real-world strategy behind baseball: how the game mechanics reflect actual decisions made by managers and players, and how statistics influence team building.

Play style

MLB 16: The Show features a flexible session rhythm; individual games can be played in under an hour, while career and season modes offer much longer, ongoing progression loops. The difficulty is scalable, allowing newcomers to learn the ropes while offering deep challenge for seasoned players. It supports both solo play in career and season modes, and social play through local and online multiplayer. Younger children might need help understanding the deeper strategic elements or navigating online settings.

Score Breakdown

Positive Aspects

Educational Value

3/5

Creativity

3/5

Pro-Social

2/5

Risk Factors

Addictive Monetization

3/5

Time Pressure / FOMO

1/5

Social Risk

2/5

Content Intensity

0/5

Why this rating

Educational Value

3/5

The game provides a deep and strategic simulation of baseball, which effectively teaches players about team management, player statistics, and game strategy. This hands-on experience in understanding the sport's intricacies contributes to its good educational value.

Creativity

3/5

The "Road to the Show" career mode allows players to create their own unique athlete and guide their development, fostering a sense of ownership and creative expression. Players make choices about their character's skills and progression, which directly influences their journey to stardom.

Addictive Monetization

3/5

The game includes a "Diamond Dynasty" mode where players collect cards and build teams, and special editions were sold with in-game currency and card packs. The mechanic of online modes costing in-game currency after initial attempts can subtly encourage spending real money on "Stubs" to continue playing, which is a moderate concern.

Social Risk

2/5

Online player-vs-player modes introduce the risk of interaction with strangers, which can be a concern for parents. While not an inherently aggressive game, any online interaction carries a degree of social risk requiring parental guidance.

Negatives

•Includes online player-vs-player modes which may involve interactions with strangers.
•Features a 'Diamond Dynasty' mode where players can acquire player cards and build a team
•special editions of the game were sold that included in-game currency ('Stubs') and card packs.
•Some online game modes cost in-game currency to enter after the first attempt, which can encourage spending.

Positives

•Provides a deep and strategic simulation of baseball, teaching players about team management, player statistics, and game strategy.
•Features a 'Road to the Show' career mode that allows for creativity through custom player creation and development.
•Offers both local and online multiplayer modes for playing with friends and other players.
•The game content is appropriate for all ages and is rated E for Everyone by the ESRB.

Gameplay Videos

MLB The Show 16 (PS3) - Gameplay

30-30 Club - Baseball Video Game Encyclopedia

1 of 3

Other Recommended Games

flOw

Sony Interactive Entertainment

73/100

Same platform, Same business model, Similar gameplay style, Higher health score

Age of Empires II: Definitive Edition

Forgotten Empires

78/100

Same platform, Same business model, Similar gameplay style, Higher health score

Arma Reforger

Bohemia Interactive

75/100

Same platform, Same business model, Higher health score

Human: Fall Flat

No Brakes Games

73/100

Same platform, Similar gameplay style, Higher health score

Official Ratings

No official ratings available.

Age Fit

ℹ️Ages 3-5

Not suitable; the complex simulation and strategic depth are beyond this age group.

ℹ️Ages 6-8

Suitable with active parental supervision; requires guidance with online modes and understanding game complexity.

ℹ️Ages 9-12

Recommended with discussion; children can grasp core mechanics but parental awareness of online interactions and monetization is important.

ℹ️Ages 13-15

Recommended; this age group can fully engage with all aspects, including strategic depth and competitive online play, but continue to discuss responsible online behavior.

ℹ️Ages 16-18

Recommended; a good fit for teens who are fans of baseball and detailed sports simulations.