GameCompass LogoGameCompass

South Park: The Fractured But Whole

South Park: The Fractured But Whole

Game images by RAWG

South Park: The Fractured But Whole

South Park: The Fractured But Whole

Ubisoft San Francisco

PC, Xbox One, PlayStation 4, Nintendo SwitchPremium
Health Score
55
DECENT

About This Game

Super Review

South Park: The Fractured But Whole offers a humorous, story-driven RPG experience strictly for mature players due to its extensive crude humor, graphic violence, and sexual content. While character creation shines, the game's satirical bite is not for all families, requiring careful consideration of its adult themes. No online play removes social risks, but the pervasive mature content demands strict age gating.

Super Review

Parent verdict

This game is a qualified fit, best reserved for older teens who are already familiar with and understand the mature, satirical nature of the South Park universe. With a "Decent" health score of 55, its offensive humor, graphic violence, and sexual content are significant concerns. Parents must weigh the game's creative combat and customization against pervasive adult themes, ensuring clear boundaries and discussions about its content.

What players actually do

  • Players design their own superhero, customizing appearance, gender, and class, which encourages creative expression.
  • Players engage in turn-based tactical combat, moving characters on a grid and using diverse abilities to outwit opponents, exercising strategic thinking.
  • Players explore the town of South Park, interacting with characters and undertaking quests to advance a story, involving problem-solving and narrative engagement.

Where it shines

  • The deep character creation allows players to truly personalize their superhero, with options for appearance, costume, gender, and class, offering significant creative freedom.
  • Tactical turn-based combat encourages strategic planning and positioning, rewarding players who thoughtfully combine hero abilities and archetypes.
  • As a single-player, story-rich adventure, the game offers no online multiplayer, eliminating social risks from interactions with strangers.

Parent watch-outs

  • The game features mature-rated content including blood and gore, cartoony dismemberment, strong language, nudity, and sexual content, which is graphically depicted.
  • References to drug use and alcohol appear frequently, including quest lines specifically built around substances.
  • Crude and offensive humor, encompassing racial jokes and sexual material, is a constant presence throughout the entire game.

Family rules worth setting

  • Set a strict age limit: Only allow play for older teens who meet the PEGI 18 or ESRB M rating due to the game's highly explicit content.
  • Discuss and filter content: Be prepared to discuss the satirical nature of offensive jokes and mature themes, or guide players away from potentially disturbing sections.

Talk about this

  • The game uses satire to comment on social issues and media. How effective do you think this approach is, and does it always land appropriately?
  • The game features a 'skin color difficulty slider' that impacts how other characters treat the player and the money they earn, but not combat difficulty. What message do you think the game is trying to send with this mechanic?

Play style

This is a single-player, story-driven RPG with no online elements. Sessions are flexible, allowing players to progress the narrative and engage in turn-based battles at their own pace. Players can choose from four combat difficulties, from Casual to Diabolic, allowing for a tailored challenge. The game can take approximately 19-29 hours to complete, depending on how much side content players engage with, with no time pressure or FOMO.

Score Breakdown

Positive Aspects

Educational Value
1/5
Creativity
4/5
Pro-Social
0/5

Risk Factors

Addictive Monetization
1/5
Time Pressure / FOMO
0/5
Social Risk
0/5
Content Intensity
4/5

Why this rating

Educational Value

1/5

South Park: The Fractured But Whole is not designed for traditional educational purposes. Its primary focus is on satire, humor, and social commentary, often using offensive themes that are aimed at an adult audience rather than providing learning value.

Addictive Monetization

1/5

The game scores very low in this risk category because it is a premium title with no microtransactions in its core gameplay. Any additional content comes in the form of optional, single-purchase story expansions rather than exploitative monetization schemes.

Creativity

4/5

Creativity is a strong benefit, as players can extensively customize their own superhero, including appearance, costume, gender, and choosing from multiple hero classes and mixing their abilities. This allows for significant personal expression and diverse playstyles.

Content Intensity

4/5

Content intensity is a major risk due to the pervasive mature-rated material, including graphic depictions of blood and gore, cartoony dismemberment, strong language, sexual content with nudity, and drug/alcohol references. The humor is often crude, offensive, and includes racial jokes.

Negatives

  • •Mature-rated content includes blood and gore, cartoony dismemberment, strong language and sexual content with nudity.
  • •Drug use and alcohol references appear, including quest lines built around substances.
  • •Crude and offensive humour, including racial jokes and sexual material, runs throughout.
  • •Not an educational game
  • •the satire and mature themes are aimed squarely at adults.

Positives

  • •Deep character creation lets players design their own superhero, customising appearance, costume, gender and class.
  • •Tactical turn-based combat rewards planning, positioning and mixing abilities across hero archetypes.
  • •A story-rich single-player adventure with no online multiplayer, so no contact with strangers.
  • •No microtransactions in the base game
  • •extra content comes as optional single-purchase story expansions.
  • •Satirical writing gives older teens material to think about how media and social issues are presented.

Gameplay Videos

South Park: The Fractured But Whole Trailer – E3 2016 [NA]

Ubisoft

1 of 3

Official Ratings

M
ESRB

Age Fit

ℹ️Ages 3-5
Not suitable for this age group due to pervasive mature themes and graphic content.
ℹ️Ages 6-8
Not suitable for this age group due to pervasive mature themes and graphic content.
ℹ️Ages 9-12
Not suitable for this age group due to graphic violence, sexual content, drug references, and offensive humor.
ℹ️Ages 13-15
Not suitable for this age group; the game is rated Mature (ESRB) and PEGI 18, with extensive sexual content, drug use, strong language, and graphic violence.
ℹ️Ages 16-18
Not suitable for under-18 teens due to 18+ mature content.

Help us rate the next game

GameCompass is free for every family and takes nothing from game studios. A coffee is what puts the next game on the list.

Buy us a coffeeWhat support pays for